B.
C.
D.
| P | Q | (P & Q) |
| T | T |
T T T |
| F | T |
F T T |
| T | F |
F T T |
| F | F |
F T F |
| P | Q | R | (P v Q) v (~P v R) |
| T | T | T |
T T T |
| F | T | T |
T T T |
| T | F | T |
T T T |
| F | F | T |
F T T |
| T | T | F |
T T F |
| F | T | F |
T T T |
| T | F | F |
T T F |
| F | F | F |
F T T |
A.
B.
A.
#1.
| X | 1. | P | |
| 2. | P | ||
| X | 3. | ~ |
NC |
| X | 4. | 3, QE | |
| X | 5. | ~(S1a
|
4, EQ |
| X | 6. | S1b & J1b | 1, EQ |
| X | 7. | J1a
|
2, UQ |
| X | 8. | J1b
|
2, UQ |
| 9. | S1a | 5, ~ |
|
| 10. | ~L1a | ||
| 11. | S1b | 6, & | |
| 12. |
J1b |
||
| 13. |
/ \ ~J1a L1a | X |
7, |
|
| 14. |
/ \ ~J1b L1b X O |
8, |
Open branches: invalid argument
#2.
| X | 1. | M1a & N1a | P |
| X | 2. | P | |
| X | 3. | ~ |
NC |
| 4. | 3, QE | ||
| X | 5. | M1b & J1b | 2, EQ |
| X | 6. | ~(J1a & N1a) | 4, UQ |
| X | 7. | ~(J1b & N1b) | 4, UQ |
| 8. | M1a | 1, & | |
| 9. | N1a | ||
| 10. | M1b | 5, & | |
| 11. |
J1b |
||
| 12. |
/ \ ~J1a ~N1a | X |
6, ~& | |
| 13. |
/ \ ~J1b ~N1b X O |
7, ~& |
Open branches: invalid argument
#3.
| X | 1. | K1a & B1b | P |
| X | 2. | P | |
| 3. | P | ||
| X | 4. | ~(B1a v K1b) | NC |
| X | 5. | K1c & D1c | 2, EQ |
| X | 6. | D1a |
3, UQ |
| X | 7. | D1b |
3, UQ |
| X | 8. | D1c |
3, UQ |
| 9. | K1a | 1, & | |
| 10. | B1b | ||
| 11. | K1c | 5, & | |
| 12. | D1c | ||
| 13. | ~B1a | 4, ~v | |
| 14. |
~K1b |
||
| 15. |
/ \ ~D1a B1a | X |
6, |
|
| 16. |
/ \ ~D1c B1c X | |
8, |
|
| 17. |
/ \
~D1b B1b
O O
|
7, |
Open branches: invalid argument