A.
#1.
#2.
B.
| 1. | ( |
P | |||
| 2. | F2ba | P | |||
| X | 3. | ~( |
NC | ||
| 4. | ( |
3, QE | |||
| X | 5. | F2ba
|
1, UQ | ||
| X | 6. |
/ \ ~F2ba (B1b & C1b) X | |
5, |
||
| 7. | B1b | 6, & | |||
| 8. | C1b | ||||
| X | 9. | ~(B1b & C1b & b=b) | 4, UQ | ||
| 10. |
/ | \ ~B1b ~C1b ~b=b X X | |
9, ~& twice | |||
| 11. |
b=b
X
|
I I | |||
All branches closed: valid argument
C.
D.
E.
#1.
#2.
#3.
A.
#1.
#2.
B.
#1.
#2.
#3.
C.
#1.
#2.