RuCCS Colloquia

Individual Coherence and Group Coherence (talk recording available)

Dr. Branden Fitelson

Tuesday, February 26, 2013, 01:00pm - 02:00pm

Rutgers University, Department of Philosophy

Copy to My Calendar (iCal) Download as iCal file

Paradoxes of individual coherence (e.g., the preface paradox) and group coherence (e.g., the doctrinal paradox) typically presuppose that deductive consistency is a coherence requirement for both individual and group judgment. In this paper, we introduce a new coherence requirement for (individual) full belief, and we explain how this new approach to individual coherence leads to an amelioration of the traditional paradoxes. In particular, we explain why our new coherence requirement gets around the standard doctrinal paradox. However, we also prove a new impossibility result, which reveals that (more complex) varieties of the doctrinal paradox can arise even for our new notion of coherence. This is joint work with Rachael Briggs, Fabrizio Cariani, and Kenny Easwaran.

There is also a (draft) manuscript that goes with this talk, which is available at:

To view a recording of this talk click here (You will need a Rutgers NetID and password)

Dr. Branden Fitelson

The RuCCS Colloquia Series is organized by Dr. Julien Musolino and Dr. Sara Pixley. The talks are held on Tuesdays in the Psychology Building, Room 101 on the Busch Campus from 1:00-2:30pm.

Note: If you would like to receive email announcements about the colloquium series, please contact the Business Office to have your name added to our announce lists at