For video footage from past you can visit the individual event pages, or go to our YouTube Channel.
List of Past Events
A General Argument Against Pragmatic Explanations
Thursday, October 04, 2012, 12:00pm - 07:00pm
Rutgers University, Department of Philosophy
If a semantic theory makes incorrect predictions, defenders often attempt to rescue the theory by appealing to Gricean pragmatics. The idea is that we can successfully rescue the theory as long as we can use Gricean pragmatics to explain why the incorrect predictions do not manifest themselves at the level of appropriate assertion. I argue that this appeal to Gricean pragmatics fails if the incorrect predictions at issue reemerge at the epistemological level of rational commitment or the metaphysical level of mere facts. This general "reformulation argument" undermines a wide variety of pragmatic “rescue attempts” in formal semantics.